Search

Giving in to Temptation

0 views
This analysis was conceived when the coauthors discovered we'd each been independently seriously tempted to buy a Mac Mini, and realized what that temptation implied. Eric Steven Raymond and Rob Landley at Our biggest problem can be summed up in one question: "What are we going to do about iTunes?" Apple's iTunes is a service that has become lifestyle-critical for tens of millions of people. Try selling Linux to any end-user under 30 and one of the first questions you're likely to hear is "Will it play with my iPod?" Of course Windows has iTunes also, but the authors are right: even I, a person with close to no interest in music, use iTunes. I've even bought music from the iTunes store and of course have ripped what little music I do enjoy off my cd's and into my computer. Media in general is a problem for Linux and the authors recognize that. They also seem to recognize that Apple is very strong here:
We can choose to fail. If we don't support the media formats that contain the content users want to see, we lose the 64-bit desktop. It's that simple. Doing nothing guarantees that we lose, probably to MacOS X.
Well, Linux isn't really going to lose. Linux already is taking over the server market, and that's probably going to continue: Apple doesn't have much traction there and Microsoft is skidding as usual. I've said before that a world of Linux servers and Mac desktops has a lot to offer: the Unix underpinnings of both OSes complement each other beautifully and would simplify support tasks enormously. That's a very pretty picture from everyone's point of view: both unsophisticated and highly technical users love Macs, the geeks in the server room have their Linux servers but are quite comfortable with the Mac command line because it's exactly the same as Linux, programmers have a very similar environment and interfaces that work together well, and support folk have a lot of knowledge cross-pollination. What's not to like? So, I suggest that Eric and Rob give in to temptation and do what I do in my home office: Linux servers and Mac desktops. It's an easy, painless switch, and I actually think it could have benefits for Linux: if more Linux programmers started concentrating on that Mac desktop/Linux server model (and vice-versa), it would hurt Microsoft and help strengthen both Linux and Apple. *Originally published at

Suggest a Correction

Found an error or have a suggestion? Let us know and we'll review it.

Share this article

Comments (0)

Please sign in to leave a comment.

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!